
Taking clues from the past while searching for an outstanding investment can be helpful, but honestly, it can only take us so far. History gives hints, not home delivery of multibagger stocks.
One logical way to find a great investment is to talk to someone who understands different parts of management properly. This person should be skilled enough to explain important areas of a company, such as its executive team, production, sales organisation, research and development, and other parts of the business. Such information can help us decide whether a company is truly an outstanding investment or just wearing a nice suit and pretending.
At first, this method sounds very sensible. But there are several reasons why it may not work well.
First, very few people who hold managerial positions in an organisation have the time, energy, or interest to sit with an investor and explain the entire company like a school teacher before exams. And even if they were willing, no growing company would allow an outsider to access all the information needed to make a fully informed decision. Companies do not usually say, “Please come in, take our secrets, and also have tea.”
Instead, an investor should search for a group of people who can be very helpful in finding a bonanza company.
This group consists of former employees.
Former employees can have a real inside view of the company’s strengths and weaknesses. Since they are no longer working there, they may speak more freely about what is good, what is bad, and what is quietly hiding under the carpet.
But there is one important warning.
The information shared by former employees can be harmful rather than helpful if the investor does not cross-check it with other people. One person’s opinion may be honest, but it may also be biased, emotional, outdated, or affected by personal experience. Maybe they left the company happily. Maybe they left with the emotional energy of a rejected movie villain. So, verification is necessary.
An investor should not depend on one source alone.
If enough different sources of information are searched about a company, there is no reason to expect that every bit of information will agree perfectly with every other bit. Different people may see the same company from different angles.
One person may praise the management.
Another may complain about the sales team.
Someone else may say the research and development department is excellent.
Another may say the production process moves slower than a government file on a sleepy afternoon.
This does not mean the information is useless. It simply means the investor must collect enough views, compare them carefully, and then form a balanced judgement.
That is the real use of scuttlebutt.
It is not gossip for entertainment. It is gossip with a purpose.
The goal is to understand the company better than what numbers alone can show. Financial statements tell us what has happened. Scuttlebutt can sometimes help us understand why it happened and whether it may continue.
So, while looking for an outstanding investment, the investor should not only read balance sheets and profit statements. They should also try to understand the people, culture, operations, customers, competitors, and reputation of the business.
Because sometimes, the best clues about a company are not sitting neatly in an annual report.
They are scattered outside it, waiting to be picked up by someone patient enough to ask the right people and careful enough not to believe everything at once.
